Best for most dogs
Ruffwear Approach Pack
Balanced saddlebags on a padded harness, and the harness works alone when the panels come off.
The sensible default, and the removable panel design is the reason. Being able to strip the pack down to a harness at a rest stop, in water, or when the dog is tiring means you are not choosing between carrying the pack yourself and leaving the dog loaded. Panel placement matters too -- weight belongs over the shoulders, and packs that slide back onto the hips are both uncomfortable and less safe. See <a href="/trail-dog/best-dog-hiking-gear">dog hiking gear</a>.
Specs
- Padded harness with removable saddlebag panels
- Four points of adjustment
- Sized by girth with published charts
- Compression straps on the panels
Good for
- The harness functions on its own once the panels are removed, which is genuinely useful at rest stops
- Four adjustment points fit a wider range of chest depths properly
- Panels sit over the shoulders rather than sliding back onto the hips
Bad at
- Sized by girth -- the wrong size makes the whole thing worse than no pack
- Padding holds water and dries slowly
- Panels catch on undergrowth in tight trails
