Best for most campers on unpowered sites
Mr. Heater Portable Buddy (MH9BX)
The default propane tent heater. Two heat settings, both safety shutoffs, and fuel you can buy at any hardware store or gas station.
This is the heater nearly everyone ends up with, and the reasons are good ones. It is radiant rather than forced-air, which matters in a tent: a fan heater spends its output warming air that leaks straight out through the mesh, while a radiant panel warms the surfaces and people in front of it. It carries both safety shutoffs that matter -- an oxygen depletion sensor that cuts the gas when oxygen in the space drops, and a tip-over switch -- and neither needs a battery to work.
Treat the manufacturer's "indoor safe" rating carefully. It means the burner is clean enough for use in a ventilated indoor space, not that a sealed tent is an engineered environment. Run it to take the edge off before bed, with vents open, with a CO alarm inside the tent, and shut it off before you sleep. The rest of a cold-weather kit matters more than the heater does -- see winter camping gear list and the R-value rules in what R-value sleeping pad do I need.
Specs
- 4,000 BTU low and 9,000 BTU high settings
- Manufacturer-rated for spaces up to roughly 225 square feet
- Oxygen depletion sensor (ODS) and accidental tip-over shutoff
- Runs on 1 lb cylinders, or a 20 lb tank with a hose and fuel filter
Good for
- Radiant heat warms you directly rather than slowly heating the air, which is the right mechanism in a drafty tent
- Both safety shutoffs are mechanical and do not depend on batteries
- 1 lb propane cylinders are the single most widely available camping fuel in the US
Bad at
- Produces carbon monoxide, which means ventilation and a CO alarm are not optional extras
- Runs a 1 lb cylinder down in roughly three hours on high, so an evening takes more fuel than people plan for
- The grille gets genuinely hot -- this is a burn hazard with kids, dogs or sleeping bags nearby
