Best for most car campers who want it to cook like a real grill
Weber Q 1200
The grill in this list that behaves most like the one in your yard: cast-iron grates, a sealed lid, and enough stored heat to sear properly.
The Q 1200 is the pick because grilling is mostly a heat-storage problem, not a heat-output problem. A thin steel grate over a burner loses its temperature the instant you lay cold meat on it, which is why cheap grills produce gray food with no crust. Cast iron holds enough energy to keep searing through the first minute, and that is the whole difference.
What you pay for it is weight and bulk, and that is a real cost on a car-camping trip where the trunk is the binding constraint. Think of this as a grill you bring when grilling is the point of the evening, and keep a stove for everything else -- see best camping stoves for the boil-water-and-fry side of camp cooking.
Specs
- 189 square inches of primary cooking area
- 8,500 BTU-per-hour stainless steel burner
- Porcelain-enameled cast-iron cooking grates
- Electronic ignition with an infinite-control valve
- Runs on a 1-pound disposable propane canister; an adapter hose is needed for a 20 lb tank
- About 31 lb; folding side tables and a carry handle; roughly 25.5 in H x 40.9 in W x 16.5 in D with the lid open
Good for
- Cast iron holds heat, so the grates stay hot when cold food hits them -- the difference between searing and steaming
- A properly sealing lid means you can cook with it closed, which makes chicken thighs and thick cuts realistic rather than a gamble
- Weber's parts and warranty support is the best in this category by a wide margin, and burners and grates are genuinely replaceable years later
Bad at
- At about 31 pounds it is the heaviest unit here that is not a griddle, and it is an awkward shape in a loaded trunk
- A 1-pound canister is a short run time at full output -- plan on carrying several, or buy the adapter hose for a 20 lb tank
- 189 square inches is a two-to-four-person grill. A group of six will be cooking in shifts
